Retail Media and the Post-Click Blind Spot for CPG Brands

Portal regularly sees bounce rates above 90% once shoppers click through to retailer sites. Founder and CEO Oliver Leigh explains why the industry's obsession with traffic is broken and what must replace it.

Topics

  • For years, consumer packaged goods (CPG) marketers have accepted a glaring blind spot as an unavoidable cost of doing business. They pour millions into off-site media campaigns across Meta, TikTok, and CTV, only to watch their carefully orchestrated data trail vanish the moment a shopper clicks through to a retailer’s online store. The prevailing assumption has always been that a click signals intent: a metric to be celebrated in monthly performance reports.

    According to Oliver Leigh, Founder and CEO of Portal, that is a flawed assumption actively burning enterprise ad spend.

    The digital advertising ecosystem has conditioned marketers to chase volume, feeding platform algorithms that dutifully find the cheapest traffic rather than genuine commercial interest. When the vast majority of those clicks bounce before a product is even viewed, the foundational metrics of off-site attribution begin to look like an expensive illusion. 

    As retail media networks build higher walled gardens and brands aggressively diversify into creator networks and social commerce, this inability to connect top-of-funnel spend to bottom-of-funnel reality has become a critical vulnerability for the enterprise C-suite.

    Leigh has spent his career navigating the friction between advertising technology and actual consumer behaviour. Having previously developed infrastructure to make media instantly shoppable, he understands the perilous gap between what martech platforms promise and how people actually buy. At Portal, he is building the connective tissue to close this ‘post-click’ blind spot, giving CPG brands the capability to track off-site media through to tangible ecommerce actions, without waiting for retailers to open their gates.

    We sat down with Leigh to challenge the industry’s obsession with traffic and explore the operational realities of measuring what actually matters.

    Portal’s data highlights a staggering 90%+ bounce rate once consumers click through to retailer sites. For a CPG marketer, that implies a massive portion of off-site media spend is essentially being set on fire. Is the problem poor creative, bad retailer UX, or is the ‘click’ fundamentally broken as a metric for intent?

    The biggest problem is the click itself. For years, CPG brands have relied on clicks as a proxy for consumer interest because they’ve had very little visibility into what happens once a customer reaches a retailer’s website. But a click tells you almost nothing about whether that individual is interested in buying a product.

    When we start working with brands, we regularly see bounce rates above 90%. That means the vast majority of consumers arriving on retailer sites are leaving almost immediately, without engaging with the product.

    It’s not necessarily that the creative is poor or that retailers are providing a poor shopping experience. The problem starts much earlier, with how campaigns are being optimised. If you ask an advertising platform to find people who are likely to click, that’s exactly what it will do. But those aren’t necessarily the users most likely to buy.

    First, we help brands move away from traffic-based campaigns and start optimising for ecommerce behaviours, whether that’s meaningful product engagement, adding something to a basket, or making a purchase. Feeding those signals back into advertising platforms helps them identify audiences more likely to buy. We’ve seen significant improvements simply by changing what campaigns are optimising towards, without needing to overhaul the creative or retailer experience.

    “Shopping involves preferences, habits, trust and often a degree of discovery that people don’t necessarily want to hand over to an algorithm.”

    A major part of Portal’s value proposition is providing real-time visibility without needing direct retailer integration. But as retailers aggressively build their own walled-garden Retail Media Networks (RMNs) to monetise their data, aren’t they inevitably going to throttle or block third-party tracking? How does Portal ensure long-term visibility if retailers lock the gates?

    I think it’s important to distinguish between what retailers are doing with their retail media networks and what we’re helping CPG brands achieve. 

    Retailers are building valuable advertising businesses around their first-party customer data, and that’s absolutely their right. But the measurement they provide is generally tied to the media they’re selling.

    We’re not trying to replace that or access their first-party data. We’re helping CPG brands measure the off-site media they’re buying themselves, whether that’s on Meta, TikTok or YouTube, and understand what happens when that traffic reaches a retailer. This allows them to compare the quality of traffic they’re sending to different retail partners, rather than relying on separate reporting environments and measurement methodologies.

    For example, we worked with John Frieda to measure paid search performance across Boots and Superdrug, tracking more than 500 add-to-basket actions and feeding over 12,000 optimisation signals back into advertising platforms, all without needing retailer integration.

    We believe this also benefits retailers. If a brand can optimise its campaigns to send more genuinely interested shoppers to a retailer, that’s better for everyone involved. We’re already having constructive conversations with retailers in different markets about how we can work together to improve those outcomes.

    From a technical perspective, Portal doesn’t interfere with retailer operations or require integration with their systems. We’ve deliberately designed the technology to work independently of retailers’ existing infrastructure, while respecting their data and operating within applicable privacy requirements.

    Ultimately, I don’t see this as a battle between brands and retailers. Both sides want better-quality traffic and more sales, and better measurement can help deliver that.

    “The technology might be developing quickly, but consumer habits don’t necessarily change at the same pace.”

    Agentic commerce is attracting enormous attention, with predictions that AI agents will increasingly research, compare and buy products on consumers’ behalf. How quickly do you think this will change the way people shop, and what will it mean for brands?

    I think agentic commerce will have a role to play, but I’m sceptical that it’s going to transform shopping as quickly or as dramatically as some people are predicting.

    We’ve seen similar promises before. I previously worked for a company developing technology that made advertising instantly shoppable, and one of the things we learnt was that consumers, particularly in Western markets, didn’t necessarily want to shop that way.

    Making something easier to buy doesn’t automatically mean people will buy it. Shopping involves preferences, habits, trust and often a degree of discovery that people don’t necessarily want to hand over to an algorithm.

    Social commerce and one-click purchasing capabilities have been around for years, yet haven’t completely changed how people shop. That doesn’t mean these technologies have failed, but adoption has been much more gradual and uneven than some of the early predictions suggested.

    I think the same caution applies to AI agents. There’s a big difference between using AI to research products or narrow down options and being comfortable letting an autonomous agent make purchasing decisions for you.

    We’re still a long way from that becoming normal behaviour for the majority of consumers. The technology might be developing quickly, but consumer habits don’t necessarily change at the same pace.

    For brands, I’d be careful about rebuilding an entire marketing strategy around a future shopping behaviour that hasn’t yet been proven at scale. There’s still an enormous amount of work to do in understanding how consumers interact with advertising and retailer websites today.

    You’ve emphasised the need for better visibility across off-site channels such as YouTube and influencer and creator networks. Connecting top-of-funnel engagement to what happens on retailer websites is notoriously difficult. How much of off-site attribution is still guesswork, and how is Portal helping to close that gap?

    A lot of it is still guesswork, particularly for CPG brands that don’t sell directly to consumers.

    If you’re a direct-to-consumer brand, you can generally see what happens after someone clicks on your advertising. You know whether they viewed a product, added it to their basket or completed a purchase, and you can use that information to improve your campaigns.

    For CPG brands, that visibility has historically disappeared when someone lands on a retailer’s website. So you’ve got all this investment going into social, video and creator campaigns, but very little understanding of whether the traffic they generate is commercially valuable.

    That’s a major limitation when you’re trying to compare channels or decide where to invest.

    What we’re doing is making those post-click ecommerce signals available to brands, so they can understand which campaigns and audiences are driving meaningful engagement once shoppers reach the retailer. Signals can also be fed back into advertising platforms through conversion pixels or APIs, allowing their algorithms to optimise towards behaviours that are much closer to a purchase.

    It doesn’t mean every attribution challenge disappears. But it does mean brands no longer have to treat every click as equal or rely solely on engagement metrics to judge whether their media is working. 

    For me, that’s a much more useful starting point than trying to draw conclusions from impressions, views and clicks alone.

    We’ve seen the benefits of this approach across different campaigns. For example, our work with Listerine saw a 104% increase in add-to-cart value and an 84% increase in product-page engagers.

    We’ve also worked with Billion Dollar Boy to connect creator activity with shopping behaviour on retailer websites. This delivered a 20% uplift in add-to-basket rate on TikTok and a 30% increase in average session time from creator-driven traffic.

    Looking ahead, how do you think retail media measurement will evolve, particularly as brands invest across more retailers and off-site channels?

    I’d like to see retail media move towards a much more consistent approach to measurement, particularly across on-site and off-site activity.

    There are some useful parallels with the development of programmatic advertising. When I started working in that industry, viewability became an important way of understanding the quality of inventory. Over time, companies such as MOAT and DoubleVerify helped establish a more consistent framework for measuring it.

    I think retail media needs something similar.

    At the moment, brands are dealing with different retailers, different advertising platforms and different measurement methodologies. That makes it incredibly difficult to compare performance or understand where investment is delivering the greatest value.

    As retail media continues to expand beyond retailers’ own websites into social, video and creator-led activity, that fragmentation is only going to become more challenging.

    My hope is that we move towards a more unified approach, where brands can assess the performance of their off-site and on-site retail media using comparable signals and standards.

    Portal is already helping to address part of that challenge, but there’s a much bigger industry conversation to be had around consistent measurement standards.

    Brands shouldn’t have to make investment decisions based on which retailer or platform provides the most accessible data. They should be able to compare performance consistently and put their budgets behind the activity delivering the best commercial results.

    ALSO READ: Martechvibe’s 2027 Conference Calendar Will Put AI-Driven Customer Journeys in Focus

    Topics

    More Like This